Brooklyn, NY – The Flatlands community is in shock after the tragic death of 45-year-old Nathaniel Thomas III, a beloved church choir singer. Thomas was fatally stabbed on Wednesday morning during his routine walk to buy a newspaper, a habit he had maintained in honor of his late father. The incident occurred around 8 a.m. near Avenue K and E. 53rd St., just six blocks from the home he shared with his ailing mother.
The attacker, identified as 24-year-old Shakel Maldonado, lived next door to Thomas. The fatal confrontation stemmed from a long-standing dispute over loud music, which had been a source of distress for Thomas’ sick mother. A year prior, Maldonado had allegedly threatened Thomas after nearly slapping him during an argument. Despite the threats, Thomas chose not to press charges, and Maldonado was taken for a psychiatric evaluation instead.
Thomas was known for his deep involvement in the Love Fellowship Tabernacle in East New York, where he had been a member since childhood. He was cherished by his community for his love of music and his unwavering faith. The news of his death has left his family and church members heartbroken. His cousin, Bernice, spoke of the pain the family is enduring, particularly as Thomas’ mother remains unaware of the tragic details surrounding her son’s death.
On social media, Ralph Bunche Terrell posted, "Pray for my friend Nathaniel Thomas III’s family and friends!" echoing the grief felt by many in the community.
Maldonado, who has no prior criminal record, has been arrested and charged with murder and weapon possession. He pleaded not guilty during his arraignment in Brooklyn Criminal Court and is currently being held without bail. Thomas’ family has expressed a strong desire for justice, with Bernice stating that Maldonado deserves a life sentence for taking her cousin’s life.
In a final Facebook post made just hours before his death, Thomas expressed his faith and gratitude, writing about God’s ability to "meet every need and make anything that’s wrong right again." His words now resonate with a community seeking solace in the wake of his untimely passing.